In a couple of days’ time there’s an anniversary that you’re probably happily unaware of – I certainly was until I was asked to write an article about it. It’s 15 years since toxins received approval from the American FDA (the Food and Drug Administration) for cosmetic use.
So for this article I have written about why that approval was such a big deal and – confession time – about my experiences with toxins over the years. Yes, I have had quite a lot of it and yes I know my face is fairly wrinkly at the moment but that’s because I haven’t had any for a while except for half-a-forehead-full about six weeks ago (and yes, only half-a-forehead-full, that was for a different article. Goodness. The things I do for work. , I’ll put the link in in case you’re interested).
Only 15 years?
If you are thinking, hang on, hasn’t toxins been around for a lot longer than 15 years? Well, you’re absolutely right. It’s a prescription drug and it was used in the 1980s to correct squinting and eyelid spasms – because how it works is that it temporarily stops muscles being able to contract (or go into spasm).
So by the 1990s doctors and dermatologists were experimenting with how it might work to damp down the muscles in the face that make wrinkles – the muscles that lift the brow into furrows, the muscles around the eye that scrunch the skin up into crows feet lines and particularly the muscles that draw the eyebrows together to give vertical frown lines
My first encounters with toxins
I started hearing whispers about toxins when I started writing about beauty in the late 1990s – it was all rather hush-hush, not that many doctors were using it and it’s hard to remember now, but almost everyone was completely horrified by the idea that vain women were resorting to injections of what the papers liked to call a ‘deadly poison’ in order to stave off the ageing process – and were often ending up with strangely frozen, waxy-looking faces as a result. Because early toxins wasn’t subtle. I was talking to Dr Tracy Mountford about this recently – she was one of the first cosmetic doctors in the UK to use toxins – and she pointed out that in the early days the protocols were all about using heavy doses to achieve total smoothness. It was all about ‘chasing the line’ – or chasing away the lines.
Back then, it seemed so scary
And people were really alarmed by it because toxins is made from botulinum toxin A – and botulinum is the most lethal toxin there is. It’s a nerve poison. But as with any substance, what makes it poisonous is the dose and the amounts of toxin in toxins are minute. So cosmetic doses of toxins are not going to poison you. If I tell you that botulinum toxin A has also been used – for decades – to reduce muscle spasms in children with cerebral palsy, and it takes around 10 times the quantity that you would have in a cosmetic dose to stop a child’s limb from spasming, that might put it into context.
But the early adopters loved it from the start
But back to faces. By the turn of the century, I was a bit baffled by toxins because public opinion was hugely against it and very fearful – but at the same time I was interviewing doctors who were using it every day and their delighted patients who couldn’t get enough of the stuff and who clearly didn’t have any problem with it. Here’s a piece from the Evening Standard which I wrote with a colleague in August 2000 (see below), with a quote from one woman saying how she would rather miss a dentist’s appointment than her toxins jab. Possibly the wrong thing to compare it to since a lot of us wouldn’t mind skipping a visit to the dentist, but you get the point.
When the FDA approved toxins, it was a very big deal – because it was the first time a prescription medicine had been approved for a cosmetic use and while FDA rulings don’t govern UK doctors, this one made the whole thing seem much more official, much more ‘OK’.
I was a relatively late starter – in 2004
I didn’t get round to trying toxins until 2004 by which time I certainly needed it – I was 41 then – and I went to a doctor recommended by a friend. It wasn’t a great success because he whacked several large doses straight across the middle of my forehead – and these big red marks swelled up… and I was on my way into the office and had forgotten my make-up bag so I had to dodge into the nearest shop that sold make-up to use their testers to cover up the damage. And then when it did settle in, it just left me with a completely blank forehead and I couldn’t stand it and ended up having a fringe cut to hide it. So that wasn’t brilliant.
But I was constantly talking to doctors and dermatologists and surgeons who were using toxins and they were always offering to treat my face, and every now and then I would say, “Ok then, go on, show me what you can do,’.
Sometimes it was great, and I’d look fresher and more rested. I always love the way it smoothes away all the stress and tension from my face – but then I hate it if I can’t move my face at all and certainly, even 10 years ago, it was quite hard to find someone who could find that happy medium where you look fresher but you don’t look fake.
Now toxins has come of age
But now, you could say that toxins has come of age and although there are still a lot of doctors doing bizarre and over-enthusiastic work with it, the great majority all aim to give people a ‘natural’ look with minimal doses, just to relax those muscles that cause the dynamic wrinkle lines rather than ‘freeze’ them. And they all know how to use toxins to balance up a face, too if, say, you have one eyebrow higher than the other.
Or if like me you tend to pull down the corners of your mouth a lot, a couple of shots into the muscles in the sides of the chin will reduce that, or if you grind your teeth, toxins in the masseter muscles in the jaw can soften that, and also makes the jawline a bit less square (and yes, over the years, I’ve tried all these things. Along with toxins in the neck because if your neck is looking stringy and over-tight, softening the muscles eases that.
So i have had a lot of toxins over time but the two great things about it are that (a) – it works and (b) it is temporary. The effects wear off over 2-6 months, depending on how much you had injected and how strong the muscles where it was injected are.
A slippery slope?
I like to let it wear off before I go and have more, just to remind myself what I look like without it, and also because I know, as with fillers and lasers and all the other cosmetic procedures, it can be a slippery slope, and it’s not hard to end up looking a bit too ‘done’.
The ‘toxins backlash’?
Because I am writing more than ever about non-surgical procedures like toxins, I am always bumping into the doctors and surgeons and dermatologists who use it – interviewing them at their clinics, or meeting them at industry conferences (where you see a lot of very weird faces). And they all say that what everyone wants is to look natural and normal – and they (the doctors) have got so good at it that with most of their clients, you really can’t tell that they’ve had treatment.
The trouble is, that means all the famous clients can get away with fibbing and saying ‘No, I’d never have toxins, I tried it once and it made me look weird, so I stopped…’. Which is really unhelpful for normal mortals wondering how these A-listers look so effortlessly fab.
So I say all this to the doctors, and ask if they have stopped giving so many toxins treatments, because if everyone who claims they’ve give it up had really given it up, well, the doctors would be out of business. And the doctors laugh and remind me that toxins and filler are their top two treatments. There is no backlash. All those people, particularly celebs, who swear they’ve given up on toxins? They’re just getting such good, subtle work it’s very hard to spot. They’re getting what Dr Sebagh, who is one of the best-known names in this whole field calls ‘actor toxins’ – where his patients can make all the expressions they need to – just not so exaggerated.
Where do I have toxins now?
So what do I have done now? For the past year or so I’ve been seeing Dr Tapan Patel at the Phi Clinic who is brilliant and who always errs on the side of caution. He sprinkles a bit of toxins around my face as and where it’s needed – . And I always go back two weeks later so he can see how it’s settling and make adjustments if necessary.
I’ll add the video in here of me having the treatment with him, from a few months ago, if you want to see what the process looks like – and I know the big question for anyone who is interested in toxins is: who should I go and see? The best answer is, someone you have a personal recommendation for. Or someone who is registered with the BCAM. I’ll put below a list of the doctors who’ve given me great toxins over the years and others who I know do great work. It’s only the tip of the iceberg, there are so many practitioners, but I hope it’s helpful.
The link to the article in the Mail is here. How I wish they had seen fit to use more serious headline, but I hear it was a direct request from the editor. And maybe that they had used a picture where I didn’t look like an android. But that’s the nature of the game.
Doctors, derms and surgeons who have done great toxins for me include:
Dr Tapan Patel and his associates at the Phi Clinic, 102 Harley Street, W1
Dr Tracy Mountford and her associates at the Cosmetic Skin Clinic, Upper Wimpole Street and Stoke Poges
Dr Sam Bunting, 25 Harley Street, W1
Dr Rita Rakus, 34 Hans Road, SW1
Dr Aamer Khan, Harley Street Skin Clinic
Mr Rajiv Grover, Harley Street
Mr Naresh Joshi, Cromwell Hospital
and others I would happily go and see because they do great work
Dr Stefanie Williams (London) Eudelo
Dr David Eccleston, (Birmingham) Medizen
Miss Sherina Balaratnam (Beaconsfield) Sthetics,
Professor Nick Lowe (Harley Street) Cranley Clinic
Dr David Jack, (Harley Street)
Dr Sarah Tonks (Chelsea) The Lovely Clinic
Dr Jean-Louis Sebagh and associates (Wimpole Street)
Mr Geoff Mullan and Dr Vicky Dondos at Medicetics
Dr Frances Prenna Jones (Mayfair)
Dr Jules Nabet, London W8
Miss Jonquille Chantrey, Alderley Edge
Dr Darren McKeown Harley Street and Glasgow
Dr Ravi Jain, Riverbanks Clinic, Harpenden
Dr Bob Khanna, DrBK Clinic, Reading
British College of Aesthetic Medicine – link here. This used to be called the British Association of Cosmetic Doctors and all members must be registered with the GMC and meet certain criteria and continue their aesthetic training, so it’s a good place to look for a practitioner.
Thérapie Clinic / Emsculpt update
I’ve now finished my four EMSCULPT treatments – so what have I noticed so far?
Price Awareness: Lip filler
Find out how much you should expect to pay for a good, safe lip filler treatment
Top tips: Lip filler
We asked three expert injectors for their top tips for anyone thinking about getting lip filler.
Please, don’t get cheap lip filler. It’s not worth it
Why it's crucial that you aren't driven by price when you get lip filler